Knowledge library
TRIGRAM-08 / Shared methods

Kun (坤): three yin lines, two sets of earth images

Content version · · Sources & references

Kun: three yin lines, two sets of earth images
Save share card ↓

Kun is the trigram of three yin lines, the inverse of Qian. Read the seven Shuo Gua chapters where it stands with Qian, the southwest in the Judgment, the list of chapter 11, and two sets of images, black and yellow.

The short version7 min read

The word Kun occurs nine times in the Shuo Gua, in seven chapters, and Qian is present in every one. Kun's figure is three yin lines, each the opposite of Qian's; in the text of hexagram 2 the earth is still the subject, but its color turns from black to yellow.

  • The word Kun occurs nine times in the Shuo Gua, in seven chapters, and Qian is present in every one; Qian comes first everywhere except chapter 5, where Kun is the fourth stop and Qian the sixth.
  • Chapter 5 gives Kun only “earth” and “nourishment”; the southwest comes from the Judgment and Commentary of hexagram 2, “gain friends in the southwest, lose friends in the northeast”, matching where the later diagram puts Kun and Gen.
  • The Shuo Gua says the earth is black and Kun is a cow, while the line texts and Wenyan of hexagram 2 say yellow skirt, mare and “heaven is dark, earth is yellow”: two texts, two sets of images.
Eighteen seconds: the three yin lines of Kun appear one by one, then where the southwest is written, the Shuo Gua or the Judgment of Kun, and three closing questions: which text, black or yellow, where the southwest comes from.

Read first

Eight Trigrams: Three-Line Structure and Basic Images, Read Through the Shuo Gua ↗

In second place: the seven chapters where Qian and Kun appear together

The figure of Kun (坤) is three broken lines, all yin, none joined from bottom to top; the memory verse calls it “Kun, six breaks”. Turn every line into its opposite and you have Qian (乾), so the two are a pair of inverse trigrams among the eight.

Kun beside Qian: Kun is three yin lines, with the image earth; Qian is three yang lines, with the image heaven. Every line is the opposite, so the two are inverse trigrams.Open the full-size diagram

Kun beside Qian: Kun is three broken lines and Qian three unbroken ones, each line the opposite of its counterpart.

The word Kun occurs nine times in the Shuo Gua (说卦), in seven chapters, and Qian is present in every one of them. The table lists the line each gives to each trigram, chapter by chapter:

ChapterQianKunChapter 4rules (7th verb)stores (8th verb)Chapter 5contends (6th stop)serves (4th stop)Chapter 7strongyieldingChapter 8horsecowChapter 9headbellyChapter 10heaven, called fatherearth, called motherChapter 11heaven, 14 itemsearth, 11 itemsChapter 5 is the only one where Kun comes before Qian; chapter 6 has only six things and neither trigram
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
ChapterQianKunChapter 4rules (7th verb)stores (8th verb)Chapter 5contends (6th stop)serves (4th stop)Chapter 7strongyieldingChapter 8horsecowChapter 9headbellyChapter 10heaven, called fatherearth, called motherChapter 11heaven, 14 itemsearth, 11 itemsChapter 5 is the only one where Kun comes before Qian; chapter 6 has only six things and neither trigram
Qian and Kun side by side in seven chapters: rules and stores, contends and serves, strong and yielding, horse and cow, head and belly, father and mother, fourteen items and eleven.

Two patterns show in the table. In chapter 4 and in chapters 7 to 11 Qian comes first and Kun after; only chapter 5 reverses this, with Kun the fourth stop of the journey and Qian the sixth. Chapter 6 gives six things one verb each, and neither Qian nor Kun appears. The “heaven and earth fix their places” of chapter 3 is traditionally read as the Qian and Kun pair, but it uses the two words heaven and earth and writes no trigram name.

The southwest: not in chapter 5, but in the Judgment

The entry on Kun in chapter 5 is short: it says only that Kun is the earth and that all things receive nourishment there, which is why the stop is called “has them serve in Kun”, and it names no direction.

The word southwest is in the text of hexagram 2 itself, once in the Judgment (卦辞) and once in the Commentary on the Judgments (彖传):

It is favorable to gain friends in the southwest and to lose friends in the northeast.

Zhou Yi, hexagram 2, Judgment (excerpt, translated here)

In the southwest it gains friends, going with its own kind; in the northeast it loses friends, and in the end there is cause to rejoice.

Zhou Yi, hexagram 2, Commentary on the Judgments (excerpt, translated here)
KanGenZhenXunLiKunDuiQianSouthwest, northeastKun, GenLater Heaven diagram: Kun in the southwest, Gen in the northeast, at opposite ends
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
KanGenZhenXunLiKunDuiQianSouthwest, northeastKun, GenLater Heaven diagram: Kun in the southwest, Gen in the northeast, at opposite ends
On the Later Heaven circle Kun stands in the southwest and Gen in the northeast, facing each other across the whole circle; the other six places are Kan, Zhen, Xun, Li, Dui and Qian.

The Later Heaven diagram puts Kun in the southwest and Gen in the northeast, matching the two directions of the Judgment; chapter 5 calls Gen “the trigram of the northeast”. So Kun’s direction has two sources: its place on the diagram comes from the order of chapter 5, while the word “southwest” is in the Zhou Yi. On the Prior Heaven diagram Kun stands in the north, following the pairs of chapter 3, and neither diagram is in the Shuo Gua itself.

Eleven items: cloth, cauldron, carriage, and “stinginess” in between

Chapter 11 gives Kun this entry:

Kun is earth, mother, cloth, cauldron, stinginess, evenness, the cow with her calf, the great carriage, pattern, the multitude, a handle. Of the earth, it is black.

Shuo Gua, chapter 11 (Kun, translated here)

Eleven items when counted, and a separate closing sentence just for the earth. The four rows below group them by content; the division is ours, not the text’s:

Earth and mothersame names as chapter 10: earth, motherObjectscloth, cauldron, great carriage, handleCow and multitudecow with calf, multitudeQualitiesstinginess, evenness, patternEleven items in four rows; the grouping is ours and the text only lists them
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Earth and mothersame names as chapter 10: earth, motherObjectscloth, cauldron, great carriage, handleCow and multitudecow with calf, multitudeQualitiesstinginess, evenness, patternEleven items in four rows; the grouping is ours and the text only lists them
Kun’s eleven images in four rows: earth and mother, two items; objects, four (cloth, cauldron, great carriage, handle); cow and multitude, two; qualities, three (stinginess, evenness, pattern).

The cow becomes “the cow with her calf” in this list, while chapter 8 writes only “Kun is the cow”. The list of Dui has a line of its own, “of the ground, it is hard and salty”, hard saline soil: speaking of the earth, Kun writes black and Dui writes salt, each taking one side.

One earth, two sets of images: black and yellow, cow and mare

The Shuo Gua assigns Kun black and the cow. In the text of hexagram 2 itself, the earth turns yellow and Kun’s animal becomes the mare:

A yellow lower garment: supreme good fortune.

Zhou Yi, hexagram 2, fifth line (translated here)

Heaven is dark, and earth is yellow.

Zhou Yi, hexagram 2, Wenyan, on the top line “its blood is dark and yellow” (translated here)
Shuo Guachapters 8 and 11Earth: “of the earth, black”Animal: cow, cow with calf“Pattern” in the listJudgment and linestext of hexagram 2Earth: yellow skirt (line 5)Animal: favorable to a mareLine 5 image: pattern withinWenyanexplanation of hexagram 2Heaven dark, earth yellowDark-yellow: heaven and earth mixedThe noble: yellow withinOne earth, three places, three choices of color and animal
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Shuo Guachapters 8 and 11Earth: “of the earth, black”Animal: cow, cow with calf“Pattern” in the listJudgment and linestext of hexagram 2Earth: yellow skirt (line 5)Animal: favorable to a mareLine 5 image: pattern withinWenyanexplanation of hexagram 2Heaven dark, earth yellowDark-yellow: heaven and earth mixedThe noble: yellow withinOne earth, three places, three choices of color and animal
Three places and Kun’s images: the Shuo Gua has black earth and the cow; the Judgment and line texts of hexagram 2 have a yellow skirt and a mare; the Wenyan has heaven dark and earth yellow.

The top line says “its blood is dark and yellow”, and the Wenyan (文言) explains those words: “dark and yellow are the mixture of heaven and earth; heaven is dark and earth is yellow.” In the Shuo Gua, dark yellow is one item in the list of Zhen, “is dark yellow”. The same two characters serve in one place for the dragon’s blood, in another as an image of Zhen, and in a third are explained as heaven and earth mixed.

The Shuo Gua puts “pattern” in Kun’s list, and the Small Image (小象) of the fifth line, which gives one line of explanation per line, says “the pattern is within”. Both use that one word, a rare place where the two texts can be joined. The Shuo Gua writes black and the Zhou Yi writes yellow because each text takes its own images and need not be forced into one; when quoting, say which place you rely on.

Yielding and carrying: from “Kun is yielding” to “carry things with thick virtue”

Chapter 7 gives Kun a single quality word:

Kun is yielding.

Shuo Gua, chapter 7 (excerpt, translated here)

The same word “yielding” appears three times in the Commentary on the Judgments of hexagram 2 and twice in the Wenyan. A second thread is “carrying”:

YieldingChapter 7Kun is yieldinginto thehexagramCommentaryfollows heavenexplainedWenyanthe way of KunCarryingChapter11great carriageinto thehexagramCommentarycarries thingsinto actionGreatImagethick virtueOne thread per row; setting the great carriage beside carrying things is a reading
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
YieldingChapter 7Kun is yieldinginto thehexagramCommentaryfollows heavenexplainedWenyanthe way of KunCarryingChapter11great carriageinto thehexagramCommentarycarries thingsinto actionGreatImagethick virtueOne thread per row; setting the great carriage beside carrying things is a reading
Two threads: yielding runs from “Kun is yielding” in chapter 7 to “it follows and receives heaven” in the Commentary and “the way of Kun is yielding” in the Wenyan; carrying runs from “the great carriage” in chapter 11 to “carries things” in the Commentary and “thick virtue” in the Great Image.

In chapter 7 yielding is a quality word; the Commentary puts it into three sentences, “it follows and receives heaven”, “gentle, yielding, favorable, steadfast” and “after, yielding, it gains constancy”, and the Wenyan has “the way of Kun, is it not yielding” and “this speaks of yielding”. The “great carriage” in the list of chapter 11 is a large cart that carries loads; the Commentary says “Kun, thick, carries things, its virtue matches the boundless”, and under this hexagram the Great Image (大象) gives what the noble person does:

The terrain is Kun; the noble person, with thick virtue, carries things.

Zhou Yi, hexagram 2, Great Image, the whole hexagram’s image text (translated here)

Reading on, yielding is a quality and carrying is what it does; setting the great carriage beside “carries things” is a reading, not a conclusion of the text.

The six-line Kun is the second hexagram, see Kun, hexagram 2; the trigram with every line opposite is Qian, and the last stop of the journey is Gen.

Questions readers ask next

Kun is “yielding”: does that mean one should simply comply?

Chapter 7 gives Kun a single quality word, “yielding”. The Commentary on the Judgments puts it into “it follows and receives heaven” and “gentle, yielding, favorable, steadfast”, which speak of how Kun takes up Qian’s lead; the sentence about what a noble person does is the Great Image’s “with thick virtue he carries things”. How far to yield, and under what conditions, has to be read in each sentence.

Where is Kun’s southwest written?

Not in chapter 5 of the Shuo Gua, which says only earth and nourishment about Kun. The southwest is in the Judgment of hexagram 2, “favorable to gain friends in the southwest”, and in the Commentary, “in the southwest it gains friends, going with its own kind”; the later diagram puts Kun in the southwest, which fits those two lines.

Is the three-line Kun the same as hexagram 2?

Keep them apart. The Shuo Gua discusses the three-line Kun; hexagram 2 is Kun over Kun, six lines. Sentences such as the mare in the Judgment, the yellow skirt and "heaven is dark, earth is yellow" belong to the six-line Kun and are not in the Shuo Gua, which is why every quotation here names its source.

Was this article helpful?

Sources & references

  1. 说卦传(Wikisource 中文版):第三至十一章 ↗
  2. 周易·坤(Wikisource 中文版):卦辞、彖传、六五爻辞、文言、大象 ↗

Continue reading

Gen (艮): yang pressed on top, and the last stop that is also the first ↗

Trigram imagery: why a round clay bowl has two possible routes ↗

Recording six coin throws: keep states and moving lines ↗