Knowledge library
BZ-TG-05 / BaZi

Indirect Wealth: why the old books call it "wealth of the many"

Content version · · Sources & references

Indirect Wealth: yang on yang, yin on yin
Save share card ↓

Indirect Wealth is the stem the Day Master controls with the same polarity; the Yuanhai Ziping defines it as "yang meeting yang wealth, yin meeting yin wealth". Then two lines in the old books and a reverse look-up.

The short version9 min read

Indirect Wealth is the stem the Day Master controls with the same polarity, and the old definition is one line: yang meeting yang wealth, yin meeting yin wealth.

  • Indirect Wealth and Direct Wealth are in the same "what I control" group and differ only in polarity: the same polarity is Indirect Wealth, the opposite is Direct Wealth. Each of the ten Day Masters has one, and the table can be read backwards.
  • The old books carry two lines at once: in family terms it is the side wife or concubine, in terms of money it is "wealth of the many". They use one character and read it differently.
  • The Sanming Tonghui does not speak of Indirect Wealth in general, but in separate passages on the month, the year and the hour, each with its own concern.
A short clip on Indirect Wealth: Yang Wood hits Yang Earth and Yin Wood hits Yin Earth, yang with yang and yin with yin; the side-wife line and the wealth-of-many line side by side; and a reminder that two editions word the officer star in opposite ways.

Read first

How the Ten Gods are derived: five relationships and two polarities ↗

Yang on yang, yin on yin: how to look it up

Yang Wood controls Earth, and Earth has two stems. Yang Earth, yang like the Day Master, is its Indirect Wealth (偏财); Yin Earth is its Direct Wealth. The rule fits in one line: the stem the Day Master controls, with the same polarity as the Day Master, is Indirect Wealth.

A stack of five layers in the order of the controlling cycle: Wood controls Earth (Yang Wood to Yang Earth, Yin Wood to Yin Earth), Earth controls Water, Water controls Fire, Fire controls Metal, Metal controls Wood. In each layer yang controls yang and yin controls yin, and the stem it lands on is the Day Master's Indirect Wealth.Open the full-size diagram

Controlling-order table: in each layer the yang Day Master is on the left and the yin on the right, and the arrow ends on its Indirect Wealth. The data come from the site's Ten Gods table.

The old definition says the same thing, more briefly:

What is called Indirect Wealth? It is yang meeting yang wealth, yin meeting yin wealth.

Opening of the section on Indirect Wealth (Yuanhai Ziping; our translation)

"Yang meeting yang wealth" means a yang Day Master looks at the yang stem it controls, and a yin Day Master does the same with yin. The five layers in the picture are stacked in the order of control, from Wood to Earth, Earth to Water, Water to Fire, Fire to Metal and Metal back to Wood. In each layer the yang stem is on the left and the yin stem on the right, the arrow starts at the Day Master and ends on its Indirect Wealth.

"Side wife" or "wealth of the many": two lines in the books

For one position the old books run two lines. One is the family line: wealth is the wife, and Indirect Wealth is the side wife. In the passage where the Sanming Tonghui (三命通会) sets out where the names come from, it begins with "what I control" and only then separates direct from indirect: Yang Wood meeting Yin Earth is the proper wife and meeting Yang Earth the side wife, and a wife is valued for being "proper, not side".

The Yuanhai Ziping (渊海子平) follows that line: for Yang Wood meeting Yang Earth its aliases are "Indirect Wealth, side wife, concubine", and in its table of family roles Indirect Wealth also stands for the father and the concubine.

The other line is money itself. The entry on Indirect Wealth in the Sanming Tonghui opens with a different wording:

What is Indirect Wealth? It is Yang Wood meeting Yang Earth and Yin Wood meeting Yin Earth: not what a wife brings, but the wealth of the many.

Opening of the Indirect Wealth section (Sanming Tonghui, juan 5)

"Not what a wife brings" folds the wife line away; "wealth of the many" says that this wealth belongs to no single person and comes from several sides. The two lines use one character and read it differently. People often say that Indirect Wealth means a windfall, but the original wording is "wealth of the many", with no sense of surprise in it.

The family linenaming passage, YuanhaiYang Wood meets Yang Earth: side wifeAliases: side wife, concubineFamily table: father, concubineThe money lineSanming Tonghui, Indirect Wealth"Not what a wife brings""The wealth of the many"Goes out freely, fears sharingOne Indirect Wealth, and the books use both a family reading and a money reading
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
The family linenaming passage, YuanhaiYang Wood meets Yang Earth: side wifeAliases: side wife, concubineFamily table: father, concubineThe money lineSanming Tonghui, Indirect Wealth"Not what a wife brings""The wealth of the many"Goes out freely, fears sharingOne Indirect Wealth, and the books use both a family reading and a money reading
Indirect Wealth has two lines in the old books: in family terms the side wife, concubine and father; in terms of money, not what a wife brings but wealth of the many, fearing division.

Month, year and hour: the books treat the pillars separately

The Sanming Tonghui does not write about Indirect Wealth in general; it speaks first of the month command and then gives the year position and the hour position a passage each. The month line reads: "Indirect Wealth carried by the month command is the heaviest, and it is not welcome to appear often among the pillars." For Indirect Wealth in the year, the book ties it to inheritance from the ancestors and mentions uncles and maternal grandparents; for the hour it opens a separate line and quotes the Xi Ji Pian (喜忌篇): "Indirect Wealth in the hour fears meeting brothers."

Carried by the month"The heaviest; not welcome to appear often"Indirect Wealth in the yeartied to the estate of ancestors, uncles, maternal sideIndirect Wealth in the houra separate line: "fears meeting brothers"Three passages, each with its own concern
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Carried by the month"The heaviest; not welcome to appear often"Indirect Wealth in the yeartied to the estate of ancestors, uncles, maternal sideIndirect Wealth in the houra separate line: "fears meeting brothers"Three passages, each with its own concern
The Sanming Tonghui treats Indirect Wealth in three passages by position: the month command carries the most weight, the year ties to the ancestors' estate, and the hour has its own line and fears meeting brothers.

Different positions, different concerns: the month asks how much weight it carries in the chart, the year connects with family background, and the hour concerns peers. That is how the book divides the topic. To apply it to a chart of your own, first find out whether the Indirect Wealth shows in a stem or inside a branch's hidden stems and which pillar it sits in; the list of hidden stems is in hidden stems.

"Splitting off" and "falling void": what Indirect Wealth fears

Once Indirect Wealth is present, the first question in the books is whether it can keep. The Sanming Tonghui quotes a line from "the classic", and the Yuanhai Ziping has a line to the same effect in its section on Indirect Wealth:

Indirect Wealth does well when it goes out and does not fear being stored away; it fears only being split off, or falling into the void.

Line quoted from "the classic" in the Indirect Wealth section (Sanming Tonghui, juan 5; the Yuanhai Ziping has a similar line)

Split off by whom? The same passage says it plainly: "above all beware of sisters and brothers splitting it off". In the Ten Gods table, what can split the wealth the Day Master controls is Companion and Rob Wealth of the same element. Take Yang Earth as the Day Master: it controls Water, with Yang Water as Indirect Wealth; its own Companion is Yang Earth and its Rob Wealth is Yin Earth, both Earth, and both control Water.

Day Master Yang EarthYang EarthDay MastercontrolsYang WaterIndirect WealthCompanion Yang EarthYang EarthCompanionalsocontrolsYang Waterthe same wealthRob Wealth Yin EarthYin EarthRob WealthalsocontrolsYang Waterthe same wealthSeveral stems of one element face the same wealth, which is what the book calls splitting off
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Day Master Yang EarthYang EarthDay MastercontrolsYang WaterIndirect WealthCompanion Yang EarthYang EarthCompanionalsocontrolsYang Waterthe same wealthRob Wealth Yin EarthYin EarthRob WealthalsocontrolsYang Waterthe same wealthSeveral stems of one element face the same wealth, which is what the book calls splitting off
The Day Master Yang Earth controls Yang Water as Indirect Wealth; Companion Yang Earth and Rob Wealth Yin Earth, also Earth, control the same Yang Water, which is the splitting off the book speaks of.

"Falling void" is another kind of thing: the branch holding the wealth falls into an empty slot, worked out as in the twelve life stages and void branches; how Companion and Rob Wealth split wealth is in Rob Wealth.

Looking it up backwards: whose Indirect Wealth is this stem?

The table often has to be used in reverse: a stem appears in a chart and the question is whose Indirect Wealth it is.

StemYang stemWhose wealthYin stemWhose wealthWoodYang WoodYang MetalYin WoodYin MetalFireYang FireYang WaterYin FireYin WaterEarthYang EarthYang WoodYin EarthYin WoodMetalYang MetalYang FireYin MetalYin FireWaterYang WaterYang EarthYin WaterYin EarthThe row head is the element of the Indirect Wealth stem: Yang Wood is the Indirect Wealth of Yang Metal
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
StemYang stemWhose wealthYin stemWhose wealthWoodYang WoodYang MetalYin WoodYin MetalFireYang FireYang WaterYin FireYin WaterEarthYang EarthYang WoodYin EarthYin WoodMetalYang MetalYang FireYin MetalYin FireWaterYang WaterYang EarthYin WaterYin EarthThe row head is the element of the Indirect Wealth stem: Yang Wood is the Indirect Wealth of Yang Metal
Reverse table: Yang Wood is the Indirect Wealth of Yang Metal, Yin Wood of Yin Metal, Yang Fire of Yang Water, Yin Fire of Yin Water, Yang Earth of Yang Wood, Yin Earth of Yin Wood, Yang Metal of Yang Fire, Yin Metal of Yin Fire, Yang Water of Yang Earth, Yin Water of Yin Earth.
  1. Find the element the Day Master controls

    The order of control is Wood, Earth, Water, Fire, Metal and back to Wood. Yang Fire is Fire, so its target is Metal.

  2. Take the stem of the same polarity

    Metal holds Yang Metal and Yin Metal. Yang Fire is yang, so Yang Metal is Indirect Wealth and Yin Metal is Direct Wealth.

  3. Check with the reverse table

    Find Yang Metal in the reverse table; its Day Master should be Yang Fire. If not, the direction of control or the polarity has been mixed up.

Two lookups and one reverse

Drill one

The Day Master is Yang Metal. Which stem is the Indirect Wealth?

Yang Metal controls Wood, and Yang Wood, with the same polarity, is Indirect Wealth.

Drill two

The Day Master is Yin Water. Which stem is the Indirect Wealth?

Yin Water controls Fire, and Yin Fire, with the same polarity, is Indirect Wealth.

Drill three

Yin Metal is the Indirect Wealth of which Day Master?

In the reverse table Yin Metal points to Yin Fire: Yin Fire controls Yin Metal and the polarity is the same.

The group before Indirect Wealth is Hurting Officer: Hurting Officer is "what I generate" and Indirect Wealth is "what I control", where this group begins.

Questions readers ask next

Is Indirect Wealth a windfall or sudden money?

The Sanming Tonghui entry says that it is not what the wife brings but "wealth of the many", meaning it belongs to no single person and comes from several sides; the entry has no sense of surprise in it.

Does the "indirect" mean less than Direct Wealth?

It is not about quantity but about polarity pairing. Within the same element, the stem with polarity opposite to the Day Master is Direct Wealth and the same polarity is Indirect Wealth. Each has its own reading; one is not the bigger or smaller of the two.

With Companion and Rob Wealth beside it, will Indirect Wealth be split away?

The book does say to beware of "brothers and sisters splitting it off", a reminder that Indirect Wealth fears being shared out by its own kind. Whether they can split it depends on the strength of the Day Master and of the wealth, and the source needs checking, because two books give opposite wordings about the officer in the same sentence.

Was this article helpful?

Sources & references

  1. 維基文庫・淵海子平(論偏財;六親;以甲為例) ↗
  2. 維基文庫・三命通會(四庫全書本)・卷五:論古人立印食官財名義、論偏財 ↗
  3. 香港天文台:天干和地支,六十干支表 ↗

Continue reading

Hurting Officer (伤官): The Stem It Generates, and Which Officer the Name Hurts ↗

Direct Wealth (正财): The Stem the Day Master Controls With Opposite Polarity ↗

Output Generates Wealth and Officer Generates Resource: Chains and Conditions ↗