Knowledge library
BZ-NY-08 / BaZi

Earth on the City Wall: Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit

Content version · · Sources & references

Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit: earth on the wall
Save share card ↓

Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit share Earth on the City Wall. Read the naming from the Tiger as a mountain, the contrast with post-road earth and the "made or unmade" rule, then check the wood it names.

The short version10 min read

Earth on the City Wall is the eighth Na Yin name, shared by Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit. The name takes the image of an embankment and city wall, and what sets the entry apart is that it reads this earth in two cases, "made" and "not yet made".

  • Both pillars are earth over wood, with each branch's Wood checking the Earth stem; Earth is at Growth on the Tiger and at Bath on the Rabbit, yet the name is a wall.
  • The Sanming Tonghui names it two ways: qi able to complete things, nurturing them from root to calyx; and both stems are earth, the Tiger is the Gen mountain, and earth piled up becomes a hill. The survey calls its work that of an embankment.
  • The entry's distinguishing mark is a two-way rule: with road earth in the chart it is made earth and needs no fire; without it, it is unmade and needs fire. Wall earth also needs wood, and Yang Metal Tiger and Yin Metal Rabbit check it in place.
Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit, Earth over Wood with the branch checking the stem; both stems Earth, the Tiger a Gen hill, earth piled into a wall; then three checks: roots or hill, the post-road pair, and the Start of Spring.

Read first

What is Na Yin in BaZi? Why Yang Wood Rat Gold in the Sea does not replace Yang Wood ↗

Earth on wood, named for a wall

The eighth Na Yin name is Earth on the City Wall (城头土), shared by Yang Earth Tiger (戊寅) and Yin Earth Rabbit (己卯). Both stems belong to Earth and both branches to Wood, so each pillar is soil sitting on timber, yet the name is that of a wall.

Table for Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit: stem, branch, Na Yin, the twelve-stage position of Earth on each branch, and whether the branch checks the stem; both pillars are Earth over Wood with the Na Yin Earth on the City Wall, Earth at Growth on the Tiger and at Bath on the Rabbit, and the Wood of each branch checks the Earth stem.Open the full-size diagram

Comparison sketch: stem and branch attributes use the usual entry-level assignments, the Na Yin name follows the Sanming Tonghui, and the stages of Earth come from the engine's twelve-stage table.

The fourth column of the table reads the twelve life stages: Earth is at Growth on the Tiger and at Bath on the Rabbit. The last column uses the element cycle: the Wood of each branch checks the Earth of its stem, in both pillars. Soil that has just been born is checked by wood at the same time, and every remark in the entry about "feeding on wood" and "checking in place" turns on that.

How the book names it: roots, calyx and the Gen mountain

The Sanming Tonghui (三命通会) gives two reasons for the name in juan 1. The first is in the general survey:

Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit: the qi can complete things, its work is to nurture them, starting from the roots and sprouts and fortifying them up to the calyx and stamens; hence earth on the city wall.

Juan 1, the city-wall earth sentence in the survey (our translation)

The earth here completes and nurtures: it carries a plant from the root sprout all the way to the calyx and stamen, and its merit lies in holding up growth. The second reason comes from the calendar specialists (日家) and turns to direction:

Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit: both stems are Earth, the Tiger is the mountain of Gen, and earth piled up becomes a mountain; hence earth on the city wall.

Juan 1, the calendar specialists on city-wall earth (our translation)

Both stems are Earth; the Tiger sits at Gen, the mountain trigram; and earth heaped up and up becomes a mountain. The specialists do not explain the step from mountain to city wall; on our reading it is earth raised high enough to hold and guard. One reason looks at function and the other at direction, and both land on earth raised high.

Reading one: functionQi completeswork is to nurtureFrom the rootsto the calyxCity Wallan embankmentReading two: directionBoth stemsare EarthTiger:Gen hillearth piled upCity Wallso it is namedThe two readings do not replace each other: one speaks of function, the other of direction
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Reading one: functionQi completeswork is to nurtureFrom the rootsto the calyxCity Wallan embankmentReading two: directionBoth stemsare EarthTiger:Gen hillearth piled upCity Wallso it is namedThe two readings do not replace each other: one speaks of function, the other of direction
Two readings of the name: qi that completes and nurtures from roots to calyx with the work of an embankment; and both stems as Earth with the Tiger as the Gen mountain, earth piled into a hill.

Set against the post road: the Tiger at Gen, the Monkey at Kun

The survey also sets this pair beside another:

Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit against Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster: city wall and post road, east and west, north and south, the proper places of Kun and Gen.

Juan 1, the paired list near the end of the section on Na Yin imagery (our translation)

Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster are Earth of the Great Post Road: the same stems, with branches half a circle from the Tiger and Rabbit. The calendar specialists' reason for post-road earth is that the Monkey belongs to Kun, the earth, and the Rooster to Dui, the marsh; earth of both stems laid over Kun and the marsh is no thin or fleeting soil.

City wallYang Earth Tiger, Yin Earth RabbitTiger is a Gen hillEarth piled into a hillWork of an embankmentEarth: Growth, BathPost roadYang Earth Monkey, Yin Earth RoosterMonkey belongs to KunRooster to Dui, marshEarth over land and lakeEarth: Weakening, DeathThe stems match and the branches sit half a circle apart; stages from the engine's Earth table in yang order; the book's single-pillar notes count from the Monkey instead
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
City wallYang Earth Tiger, Yin Earth RabbitTiger is a Gen hillEarth piled into a hillWork of an embankmentEarth: Growth, BathPost roadYang Earth Monkey, Yin Earth RoosterMonkey belongs to KunRooster to Dui, marshEarth over land and lakeEarth: Weakening, DeathThe stems match and the branches sit half a circle apart; stages from the engine's Earth table in yang order; the book's single-pillar notes count from the Monkey instead
Earth on the City Wall, Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit, against Earth of the Great Post Road, Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster: the Tiger is a Gen hill with earth piled up, the Monkey belongs to Kun and the Rooster to the marsh; Earth is at Growth and Bath against Weakening and Death.

The two groups draw on different material: city-wall earth relies on a mountain and post-road earth on land and marsh. The stages on the table also run the other way, Growth and Bath on the Tiger and Rabbit but Weakening and Death on the Monkey and Rooster. Stages do appear in the book, but on a different scale. Its notes on single pillars call Yang Earth Tiger "injured earth, the weakest of all" and Yin Earth Rabbit "earth at its own Death"; the post-road entry calls Yang Earth Monkey "earth at Growth" and Yin Earth Rooster "earth at its own defeat". Those verdicts hold only if Earth is born on the Monkey and sickens on the Tiger, as Water does: a mirror image of the engine, whose Earth keeps Fire's cycle. We print the engine's stages and quote the book beside them without merging the two.

Made or unmade: the entry's two-way rule

The entry for city-wall earth is distinctive for splitting this earth into two cases:

This earth is either made or not yet made, and is argued in two ways. When it meets earth by the road it is made earth and needs no fire; without earth by the road it is unmade earth and must use fire. In general wall earth needs wood to feed it.

Juan 1, the city-wall entry on made and unmade (our translation)

Earth by the road is Yang Metal Horse and Yin Metal Goat. With it in the chart the earth counts as "made" and gains nothing from fire; without it the earth is "unmade" and fire has to bake it. The thrust of the entry is "feed on wood", and the test below is only its first step:

Case oneCity Wallearth by the road is in the chartMade earthno fire neededCase twoCity Wallno earth by the roadUnmade earthfire is neededOnly after these two cases does the entry turn to wood and water
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Case oneCity Wallearth by the road is in the chartMade earthno fire neededCase twoCity Wallno earth by the roadUnmade earthfire is neededOnly after these two cases does the entry turn to wood and water
The two-way rule for city-wall earth: with earth by the road in the chart it is made earth and needs no fire; without it, it is unmade earth and needs fire.

Next comes the arrangement for wood:

City earth generally needs wood to feed it: willow with Yin Water Goat is best and Yang Water Horse is avoided; mulberry with Yin Water Ox is first and Yang Water Rat next; Yang Metal Tiger and Yin Metal Rabbit, checking it in place, make the wall fall and unsettle it.

Juan 1, the city-wall entry on wood (our translation)
PairingNa YinBook saysOn the tableYin Water GoatWillow WoodBestStems join; Rabbit-GoatYin Water OxMulberry WoodFirstEarth, Water stems joinYang Metal Tiger +Pine, Cypress pairChecks in placeSame branches; Wood checksYang Water DogWater of the Great SeaYang Water Dog not avoidedTiger-Dog; Rabbit-Dog joinRight column from the engine's tables; "+" stands for Yang Metal Tiger with Yin Metal Rabbit; the book gives verdicts and no reasons
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
PairingNa YinBook saysOn the tableYin Water GoatWillow WoodBestStems join; Rabbit-GoatYin Water OxMulberry WoodFirstEarth, Water stems joinYang Metal Tiger +Pine, Cypress pairChecks in placeSame branches; Wood checksYang Water DogWater of the Great SeaYang Water Dog not avoidedTiger-Dog; Rabbit-Dog joinRight column from the engine's tables; "+" stands for Yang Metal Tiger with Yin Metal Rabbit; the book gives verdicts and no reasons
City-wall earth with Yin Water Goat, Yin Water Ox, Yang Metal Tiger and Yin Metal Rabbit, or Yang Water Dog: the book's verdicts best, first, checks in place so the wall falls, and Yang Water Dog not avoided, with the table entries for stem combinations, a half union of Rabbit and Goat, Wood checking Earth, and the unions of Tiger and Dog and of Rabbit and Dog.

Row by row: the Yang Earth of Yang Earth Tiger and the Yin Water of Yin Water Goat or Yin Water Ox make one of the five stem combinations, while the Rabbit of Yin Earth Rabbit and the Goat of Yin Water Goat are two of the three in the Pig-Rabbit-Goat wood union; Yang Metal Tiger and Yin Metal Rabbit occupy the same branches as Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit, and wood checks earth, hence "checking in place". Yang Water Dog is water of the great sea: the entry first says to avoid Thunderbolt Fire and the great sea, then that Yang Water Dog is not to be avoided and its unions count as auspicious; the book does not say which union it means. More than one fits on the table: among branches the Tiger and Dog form a half union of fire and the Rabbit and Dog combine, and the other great-sea pillar, Yin Water Pig, joins Yang Earth Tiger through the Yang Earth and Yin Water stem combination. We list them and do not choose for the book.

4 February 1999: two year pillars in one day

A Yang Earth Tiger year is 1998 and a Yin Earth Rabbit year is 1999; sixty years on they are 2058 and 2059, and sixty years back 1938 and 1939. The Start of Spring in 1999 falls at 14:57 on 4 February (Beijing time), against 08:56 in 1998 and 20:40 in 2000. Looking at 4 February 1999 alone, the turn of spring splits the morning from the evening.

Year pillar Yang Earth TigerYear pillar Yin Earth RabbitStart of Spring 14:5710:00 · Yang Earth Tiger20:00 · Yin Earth RabbitThe axis is the hour of the day on 4 February 1999; before the Start of Spring the year pillar is still last year's Yang Earth Tiger
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Year pillar Yang Earth TigerYear pillar Yin Earth RabbitStart of Spring 14:5710:00 · Yang Earth Tiger20:00 · Yin Earth RabbitThe axis is the hour of the day on 4 February 1999; before the Start of Spring the year pillar is still last year's Yang Earth Tiger
Born before 14:57 on 4 February 1999 the year pillar counts as Yang Earth Tiger, born later as Yin Earth Rabbit; the Na Yin, Earth on the City Wall, is the same for both.

Two judgments

Exercise one

Yang Earth Tiger meets Yin Water Ox and the book says "mulberry with Yin Water Ox is first". What can the table confirm?

Yang Earth and Yin Water make one of the five stem combinations, and that is as far as the check goes; the book gives no reason for "first", so this row can only be confirmed at the level of the stem combination.

Exercise two

A chart holds city-wall earth and earth by the road. Read it as made or unmade?

By the entry, meeting earth by the road means made earth, needing no fire; only without it is the earth read as unmade and fire required. Check for earth by the road first, then go on to wood.

The previous pair is Water Below the Ravine and the next is White Wax Metal. The cycle in which wood checks earth and earth gives birth to metal is drawn out in full in the cycles of the five elements.

The combination of Yang Earth with Yin Water is in the five stem combinations, while the half union and harmony of the branches are a separate kind of relation. How the two layers split the work is set out in what Na Yin keeps and what stems and branches keep.

Questions readers ask next

The pillar commentary calls Yang Earth Tiger "injured earth" and Yin Earth Rabbit "earth at its own Death". Are people born in those years weak?

No. Both phrases judge the earth of the year pillar itself: in the book's count, with Earth travelling with Water, Earth sits at Weakening on the Tiger and at Death on the Rabbit, and the branch wood checks it as well, hence "injured" and "without strength"; the commentary goes on to ask for strong, living fire to feed it. The site's table runs Earth with Fire, giving Growth and Bath, and both counts coexist. Neither is a verdict on the health or fortunes of the person.

Does "made" and "unmade" say whether someone has already succeeded?

No. These are the entry's two ways of reading this earth: if the chart holds earth by the road, treat the earth as already formed and add no fire; if not, treat it as unformed and use fire to bake it. Made and unmade describe the state of the earth and not the circumstances of a person.

Why are the city wall and the great post road so often set side by side?

The Sanming Tonghui sets Yang Earth Tiger and Yin Earth Rabbit against Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster: the stems match and the branches sit half a circle apart. The Tiger belongs to Gen, in the northeast, and the Monkey to Kun, in the southwest. City-wall earth is earth piled into a hill; post-road earth is earth laid over land and lake, so their images lie in different directions.

Was this article helpful?

Sources & references

  1. 維基文庫・三命通會(四庫全書本)・卷一 ↗
  2. 香港天文台:天干和地支,六十干支表 ↗

Continue reading

Water Below the Ravine (涧下水): Why Yang Fire Rat and Yin Fire Ox Carry This Na Yin Name ↗

White Wax Metal (白蜡金): Why Yang Metal Dragon and Yin Metal Snake Carry This Na Yin Name ↗

Five Elements cycles: learn the relationships, not just the order ↗