Knowledge library
BZ-SS-21 / BaZi

Yin-Yang Mismatch: twelve fixed pillars

Content version · · Sources & references

Yin-Yang Mismatch: twelve pillars
Save share card ↓

Yin-Yang Mismatch needs no conversion: the day or hour pillar itself must be one of twelve fixed pillars. A table, the Sanming Tonghui entry and three demonstration charts show how to spot it and where the site differs.

The short version8 min read

Yin-Yang Mismatch involves no conversion: it checks whether the day pillar and the hour pillar themselves are among twelve fixed pillars. The twelve are exactly six clashing branch pairs, each pair taking one shared stem.

  • The twelve are Yang Fire Rat and Horse, Yin Fire Ox and Goat, Yang Earth Tiger and Monkey, Yin Metal Rabbit and Rooster, Yang Water Dragon and Dog, Yin Water Snake and Pig: each clashing pair takes one stem.
  • The Sanming Tonghui, juan 3, lists exactly these twelve days and says two or three hits among the month, day and hour weigh more. The site checks only the day and hour pillars and not the month, a difference from the book.
  • The book's comments concern in-law relations; the site wording, "timing easily out of step", is a milder modern phrasing of the book's "seldom in accord". Laid into the sixty-cycle, the twelve make four runs of three days.
Eighteen seconds: twelve pillars in six clashing pairs, a chart whose Yin Fire Goat day and Yang Fire Horse hour are each marked, and three checks to close.

Read first

Symbolic Stars in BaZi: Check the Reference and Rule Before the Meaning ↗

Twelve pillars, six clashing pairs

Like Kui Gang, Yin-Yang Mismatch (阴阳差错) involves no conversion. It checks whether the day pillar and the hour pillar themselves are one of twelve fixed pillars. If one is, it is marked once on that pillar.

Table of the twelve Yin-Yang Mismatch pillars laid out by the six clashing branch pairs: Rat and Horse take Yang Fire, Ox and Goat take Yin Fire, Tiger and Monkey take Yang Earth, Rabbit and Rooster take Yin Metal, Dragon and Dog take Yang Water, Snake and Pig take Yin Water, two pillars for each pair.Open the full-size diagram

Table of the twelve pillars, laid out by clashing branch pairs. The values were checked against the site's engine and match the original entry of Sanming Tonghui juan 3 word for word.

The six rows are the six clashing pairs of branches: Rat and Horse, Ox and Goat, Tiger and Monkey, Rabbit and Rooster, Dragon and Dog, Snake and Pig. Each pair takes one shared stem: Yang Fire, Yin Fire and Yang Earth for the first three pairs, then Yin Metal, Yang Water and Yin Water for the last three, twelve pillars in all. This tidy structure only shows once the twelve are laid out in a table; the original entry simply lists them one after another.

The original entry in Sanming Tonghui juan 3

The source of this sha is the section "On miscellaneous sha from stem and branch characters" in juan 3 of the Sanming Tonghui (三命通会), and the entry opens with the list:

Yin-Yang Mismatch sha: Yang Fire Rat, Yin Fire Ox, Yang Earth Tiger, Yin Metal Rabbit, Yang Water Dragon, Yin Water Snake, Yang Fire Horse, Yin Fire Goat, Yang Earth Monkey, Yin Metal Rooster, Yang Water Dog, Yin Water Pig, twelve days.

Sanming Tonghui, juan 3, first sentence of the entry; our translation

The site's table matches this list word for word. The entry goes on with comments concerning in-law relations: for a woman who meets it, relations with the husband's parents and the wives of his brothers are said to be seldom in accord; for a man, relations with his wife's family. It adds that the sha applies to either sex. The entry then says how to count:

Two or three hits among month, day and hour weigh very heavily; even the day alone weighs especially heavily.

Sanming Tonghui, juan 3, same entry, excerpt; our translation

The book counts three pillars: month, day and hour. The site's engine checks only the day and hour pillars and leaves out the month. The code does not say why, so the source is still to be verified, and this article does not invent a reason for it.

Sanming Tonghuijuan 3 entryTwelve fixed pillarsReads month, day, hourTwo or three hits weigh moreComments on in-law tiesSite engineextended tierThe same twelve pillarsReads day and hour onlyMarks each of them onceText: timing out of stepThe list agrees, the range of pillars does not; leaving out the month is the site's choice
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Sanming Tonghuijuan 3 entryTwelve fixed pillarsReads month, day, hourTwo or three hits weigh moreComments on in-law tiesSite engineextended tierThe same twelve pillarsReads day and hour onlyMarks each of them onceText: timing out of stepThe list agrees, the range of pillars does not; leaving out the month is the site's choice
Book against site: the list of pillars agrees; the book counts month, day and hour while the site checks only day and hour; the book comments on in-law relations while the site text says timing is easily out of step.

Juan 7, in its section on women's charts, has a further note on days like the Lone Phoenix (孤鸾) and Yin-Yang Mismatch:

If there is an Officer or Killings star to lean on, then even meeting days such as the Lone Phoenix or Yin-Yang Mismatch turns favorable.

Sanming Tonghui, juan 7, a note in the chapter on women's charts, our translation

The first half of that note covers the other case: a chart with no Officer or Killings star at all should take such days with care. So the book treats it as a conditional reading and not as a verdict on sight.

Laid into the sixty-cycle: four runs of three days

Put the twelve back into the sixty-cycle, counting Yang Wood Rat as position 1. They fall at positions 13 to 15, 28 to 30, 43 to 45 and 58 to 60, which are the last three days of each block of fifteen:

PositionFirst daySecond dayThird day13–15Yang Fire RatYin Fire OxYang Earth Tiger28–30Yin Metal RabbitYang Water DragonYin Water Snake43–45Yang Fire HorseYin Fire GoatYang Earth Monkey58–60Yin Metal RoosterYang Water DogYin Water PigPositions follow the sixty-cycle with Yang Wood Rat as 1; checked by scanning all sixty day pillars
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
PositionFirst daySecond dayThird day13–15Yang Fire RatYin Fire OxYang Earth Tiger28–30Yin Metal RabbitYang Water DragonYin Water Snake43–45Yang Fire HorseYin Fire GoatYang Earth Monkey58–60Yin Metal RoosterYang Water DogYin Water PigPositions follow the sixty-cycle with Yang Wood Rat as 1; checked by scanning all sixty day pillars
The twelve pillars sit at positions 13 to 15, 28 to 30, 43 to 45 and 58 to 60 of the sixty-cycle: Yang Fire Rat, Yin Fire Ox, Yang Earth Tiger; Yin Metal Rabbit, Yang Water Dragon, Yin Water Snake; Yang Fire Horse, Yin Fire Goat, Yang Earth Monkey; Yin Metal Rooster, Yang Water Dog, Yin Water Pig.

This is a regularity read off the table; the book does not say it, and it does not explain where the name comes from. It does show that the twelve are not a loose list: the first run and the third, and the second and the fourth, are thirty places apart, half a sixty-cycle. Thirty places on, the stem stays and the branch becomes the one that clashes, which is why every clashing pair shares one stem.

Three charts, checked once

The three charts are only demonstrations. The hour stems follow from the day stem in each, so the day and hour pillars in all three are valid combinations.

Chart one: Yin Wood Rabbit, Yin Earth Ox, Yin Fire Goat, Yang Fire HorseYin FireGoaton the listthenYang FireHorseon the listresultSitemarks twiceChart two: Yang Wood Rat, Yang Fire Rat, Yang Metal Horse, Yang Fire RatYang MetalHorsenot listedthenYangFire Raton the listresultSitemarks hourChart three: Yang Fire Monkey, Yin Metal Rabbit, Yang Wood Rat, Yang Wood RatYin MetalRabbiton the listthenYangWood Ratnot listedresultSiteno markcompareBookhas monthResults were checked with the site's engine; chart three shows the site and the book count different pillars
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Chart one: Yin Wood Rabbit, Yin Earth Ox, Yin Fire Goat, Yang Fire HorseYin FireGoaton the listthenYang FireHorseon the listresultSitemarks twiceChart two: Yang Wood Rat, Yang Fire Rat, Yang Metal Horse, Yang Fire RatYang MetalHorsenot listedthenYangFire Raton the listresultSitemarks hourChart three: Yang Fire Monkey, Yin Metal Rabbit, Yang Wood Rat, Yang Wood RatYin MetalRabbiton the listthenYangWood Ratnot listedresultSiteno markcompareBookhas monthResults were checked with the site's engine; chart three shows the site and the book count different pillars
Three charts: Yin Wood Rabbit, Yin Earth Ox, Yin Fire Goat, Yang Fire Horse has day Yin Fire Goat and hour Yang Fire Horse both on the list, marked twice; Yang Wood Rat, Yang Fire Rat, Yang Metal Horse, Yang Fire Rat has only the hour Yang Fire Rat on the list, marked once; Yang Fire Monkey, Yin Metal Rabbit, Yang Wood Rat, Yang Wood Rat has the month Yin Metal Rabbit on the list but the site does not read the month, so no mark.

Chart one is Yin Wood Rabbit, Yin Earth Ox, Yin Fire Goat, Yang Fire Horse (乙卯 己丑 丁未 丙午), chart two is Yang Wood Rat, Yang Fire Rat, Yang Metal Horse, Yang Fire Rat (甲子 丙子 庚午 丙子), and chart three is Yang Fire Monkey, Yin Metal Rabbit, Yang Wood Rat, Yang Wood Rat (丙申 辛卯 甲子 甲子), listed with the year pillar first and the hour pillar last.

The month pillar of chart three, Yin Metal Rabbit, is among the twelve, and the site does not mark it because it checks only the day and hour. The book counts the month too, so this is a difference between the site and the book and not a feature of that chart.

One day pillar on several lists

The twelve days overlap or resemble other lists in three places, and they should not be mixed up. The Qing almanac manual Xieji Bianfang Shu (协纪辨方书) has two lists called Yang Error (阳错) and Yin Error (阴错) in juan 4:

Yang Water Dragona Kui Gang day pillar that is also among the twelve; marked once by eachYang Earth Monkey, Yang Fire Horsealso on the Sanming Tonghui list of Lone Phoenix days; the site has no Lone PhoenixYang Error, Yin Errortwo lists in Xieji Bianfang Shu juan 4, worked out by month; unrelated hereLists with similar names and days each have their own source
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Yang Water Dragona Kui Gang day pillar that is also among the twelve; marked once by eachYang Earth Monkey, Yang Fire Horsealso on the Sanming Tonghui list of Lone Phoenix days; the site has no Lone PhoenixYang Error, Yin Errortwo lists in Xieji Bianfang Shu juan 4, worked out by month; unrelated hereLists with similar names and days each have their own source
Yang Water Dragon is both a Kui Gang day pillar and a Yin-Yang Mismatch day pillar; Yang Earth Monkey and Yang Fire Horse are also on the Lone Phoenix list, which the site does not have; the Yang Error and Yin Error lists of the Xieji Bianfang Shu are worked out by month and are unrelated to these twelve.

Yang Water Dragon is an interesting case: of the four Kui Gang day pillars, Yang Water Dragon is also among the twelve, so a chart with that day pillar shows two Symbolic Stars, each with its own source. They should not be read as one meaning.

The site's text says "a sense of mismatch in marriage and family ties, timing easily out of step with the other person, needing more spoken clarity than silent understanding", which corresponds to the book's "seldom in accord" and takes the milder end of it. How clashing branches are usually read is in the general reading of clash and punishment. How much weight such a sha carries in a whole chart is the subject of where Symbolic Stars sit in a reading, and the next one, counted from the year branch, is Heavenly Joy.

Questions readers ask next

My month pillar is Yin Metal Rabbit, which is on the list. Why does the site not mark Yin-Yang Mismatch?

The site's engine checks only the day and hour pillars and does not look at the month. The Sanming Tonghui, juan 3, counts month, day and hour together. Why the engine leaves the month out is not stated in the code, so the source is still to be verified and this article does not invent a reason.

Does Yin-Yang Mismatch mean a marriage will go wrong?

It should not be read that way. The book's comments are about in-law relations and use words like "seldom in accord"; the site rephrases this as "timing easily out of step, so say things out loud". It is a supporting clue, and juan 7 adds a note that a chart with an Officer or Killings star to lean on may find such days favorable instead, so read it with the whole chart.

My day and hour pillars are both on the list. Is it counted twice?

The site marks it once on the day pillar and once on the hour pillar, so two entries appear. The book also says "two or three hits in month, day and hour weigh heavily" and treats overlap as heavier; the site makes no judgment of degree and only tells you which pillar it landed on.

Was this article helpful?

Sources & references

  1. 維基文庫・三命通會(四庫全書本)・卷三 ↗
  2. 維基文庫・三命通會(四庫全書本)・卷七 ↗
  3. 維基文庫・欽定協紀辨方書(四庫全書本)・卷四 ↗
  4. 香港天文台:天干和地支,六十干支表 ↗

Continue reading

Kui Gang (魁罡): Four Day Pillars, Read from the Day Pillar Alone ↗

Heavenly Joy (天喜): The Branch Opposite Red Phoenix, and Other Tables of That Name ↗