Knowledge library
TRIGRAM-03 / Shared methods

Li (离): the hollow middle, clinging and the south

Content version · · Sources & references

Li: the hollow middle, clinging, the south
Save share card ↓

Li has two yang lines around a broken yin line. Follow its word, clinging, through three Ten Wings texts, then chapter 5 on facing the light, the shelled creatures of chapter 11, and the pheasant versus the cow.

The short version6 min read

The word the Shuo Gua gives Li is clinging; chapter 5 places it in the south and says that the sage governs turned toward the light. The figure is a broken yin line held between two yang lines.

  • Turn Li upside down and it is still Li; swap every line and you get Kan. Li and Kan are inverses, and chapter 3 writes them as "water and fire do not shoot at each other".
  • Clinging means attaching to something: the Commentary on the Judgments says sun and moon cling to heaven, grain and plants to the soil, and the Xu Gua says what sinks must cling to something.
  • The chapter 11 list for Li starts with fire, sun and lightning and goes on to the turtle, crab, snail, clam and tortoise, creatures that carry shells.
Eighteen seconds: Li's yin line held between two yang lines; flipped it stays Li, swapped line by line it becomes Kan; then three questions: is this Qian read gān, what does it cling to, is "hard outside" in the text.

Read first

Eight Trigrams: Three-Line Structure and Basic Images, Read Through the Shuo Gua ↗

A broken line in the middle: Li turned over is still Li

Li (离) has two yang lines around one broken yin line, and the mnemonic students used later remembers it as "hollow in the middle". The shape has one odd property: turn it upside down and what you see is the same trigram.

Li beside Kan: Li has a broken yin line between two yang lines, with the image fire; Kan has a yang line between two yin lines, with the image water. Every line is the opposite of its partner, so they are inverses.Open the full-size diagram

Li beside Kan: every line is opposite, which makes the pair inverses; Li's image is fire and Kan's is water.

The other change is a swap of polarity: replace all three lines with their opposites and you get Kan (坎). Li and Kan are therefore inverses, and chapter 3 of the Shuo Gua (说卦) sets them side by side as a pair, saying of water and fire that they "do not shoot at each other".

Turned upside downLiyang, yin, yangflipLiunchangedPolarity swappedLiyang, yin, yangswapKanyin, yang, yinFlipping leaves Li as it is; only the swap produces its inverse, Kan
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Turned upside downLiyang, yin, yangflipLiunchangedPolarity swappedLiyang, yin, yangswapKanyin, yang, yinFlipping leaves Li as it is; only the swap produces its inverse, Kan
Li turned upside down is still Li; swapping every line of Li gives Kan.

Clinging, and what it clings to

The word chapter 7 gives to Li is clinging. The Commentary on the Judgments (彖传) adds examples, and the Xu Gua (序卦) starts from Kan:

Clinging in three texts

Chapter 7

Li is clinging

One of the eight nature words. Clinging means attaching, holding on.

Commentary on the Judgments

Sun and moon cling to heaven; grain and plants cling to the soil

Two sets of examples: sun and moon attach to the sky, crops and plants attach to the earth, each with its own support.

Xu Gua

What sinks must cling to something

Sinking is Kan's word. Whatever has fallen in needs something to hold, and so the next hexagram is Li.

The word is the same character in all three places, and in each it means having something to hold on to. Later readers often see the figure this way: the middle yin line holds on between two yang lines. That is a reading of the picture; the texts give only the word and the examples. The Great Image of Dui uses the same character in its phrase for lakes joined together, which is taken up in the Dui trigram.

Facing the light: the south in chapter 5

Of the eight trigrams, Li receives the longest entry in chapter 5:

Li is brightness. All things see one another there. It is the trigram of the south. The sage faces south to hear the world and governs turned toward the light; the practice is taken from this.

Shuo Gua, chapter 5, our translation

Brightness is another word for Li. That things can see one another belongs to the light of the south, and the sage faces south to take in the affairs of the world, a practice drawn from this trigram.

KanGenZhenXunLiKunDuiQianToward lightsage faces southLater Heaven diagram: north at top, clockwise; Li in the south
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
KanGenZhenXunLiKunDuiQianToward lightsage faces southLater Heaven diagram: north at top, clockwise; Li in the south
Later Heaven layout read around from the north at the top: Kan, Gen, Zhen, Xun, Li, Kun, Dui, Qian, with Li facing due south.

The Later Heaven diagram therefore puts Li in the south. On the Prior Heaven diagram Li is in the east, opposite Kan in the west. Li's one position rests on a sentence of chapter 5 and the other on the pairing of chapter 3.

Fire, sun and lightning, and creatures with shells

The chapter 11 entry for Li opens:

Li is fire, the sun, lightning, the middle daughter, armor, spears and weapons.

Shuo Gua, chapter 11 (Li)

Fire, sun and lightning give light and heat; armor and weapons are hard-faced things made by hand. Next comes "in people":

In people: a big belly. Dryness, the soft-shelled turtle, the crab, the snail, the clam, the tortoise.

Shuo Gua, chapter 11 (Li)

How far "in people" reaches depends on the punctuation: the Wikisource text runs everything after it on, while the Kanripo text stops after "a big belly" and start the dryness and shell list afresh. The word rendered "dryness" is the character that also names Qian, but traditionally it is read gān, "dry", and is not the trigram. The five that follow, turtle, crab, snail, clam and tortoise, are all animals that carry a shell. The last clause holds a single item, "among trees, one hollow with a withered top", traditionally explained as a trunk empty inside and dry at the crown.

Light and heatFireSunLightningHard or shelled outsideobjects and animalsArmorWeaponsTurtle, crab, snail, clam, tortoiseThe restMiddle daughterBig bellyDryness (read gān)Hollow treeThe grouping is ours; the text lists the items side by side
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Light and heatFireSunLightningHard or shelled outsideobjects and animalsArmorWeaponsTurtle, crab, snail, clam, tortoiseThe restMiddle daughterBig bellyDryness (read gān)Hollow treeThe grouping is ours; the text lists the items side by side
The list for Li in three groups: fire, sun, lightning; armor, weapons and turtle, crab, snail, clam, tortoise; middle daughter, big belly, dryness, hollow tree.

The pheasant and the cow: two animals for one Li

Chapter 8 gives Li the pheasant. In the judgment of the six-line Li, though, the animal is a cow:

Keeping a cow brings good fortune.

Zhouyi, Li, judgment

The Commentary on the Judgments explains that cow itself:

The yielding clings to the center and the right place, therefore it prospers; hence keeping a cow brings good fortune.

Zhouyi, Li, Commentary on the Judgments

The yielding is the yin line, which holds to a central, correct position, and from there the Commentary comes to the gentle cow.

WhereAnimalBasisShuo Gua ch. 8Pheasantthe animal of LiJudgment of LiCowCommentary: the yielding clingsShuo Gua ch. 8Oxthis one belongs to KunOne trigram gets different animals in different texts
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
WhereAnimalBasisShuo Gua ch. 8Pheasantthe animal of LiJudgment of LiCowCommentary: the yielding clingsShuo Gua ch. 8Oxthis one belongs to KunOne trigram gets different animals in different texts
Li has the pheasant in chapter 8 and the cow in the judgment of the hexagram, while the ox of chapter 8 belongs to Kun.

Images serve their own statements in their own texts, and the pheasant of chapter 8 and the cow of the judgment are not on one list. The Great Image of the six-line Li reads "brightness doubled makes Li; the great person lights the four quarters by carrying on the brightness", with "great person" as subject rather than "noble person"; it is read in Li, the hexagram. To keep going with the partner of Li, move on to the Kan trigram.

Questions readers ask next

Is the "Qian" in the chapter 11 list for Li the trigram Qian?

No. Here the character is traditionally read gān, "dry", and only happens to be the character that names Qian. When a familiar character turns up, look at the sentence it stands in before deciding what it refers to.

Why is clinging called the nature of Li?

Chapter 7 gives the word to the trigram and the Commentary on the Judgments says "Li is clinging". Clinging means attaching: sun and moon attach to heaven, grain and plants to the soil. That pairing is written out by the Ten Wings themselves.

Li is fire, so why is its animal a pheasant, and why does a cow appear in the judgment?

Each text says its own thing. Chapter 8 gives Li the pheasant, the judgment of the hexagram speaks of keeping a cow, and the Commentary explains the cow by the yielding line clinging to the central, correct place. Images serve different statements in different texts; they are not one list.

Was this article helpful?

Sources & references

  1. 说卦传(Wikisource 中文版):第三、五、七、八、十一章 ↗
  2. 周易·離(Wikisource 中文版):卦辞、彖传“離,麗也”、大象“明兩作” ↗
  3. 序卦传(Wikisource 中文版):“陷必有所麗” ↗
  4. Kanseki Repository KR1a0001 周易(漢籍リポジトリ):說卦 ↗

Continue reading

Dui (兑): a gap at the top, and the word "delight" seven times in the Shuo Gua ↗

Zhen (震): yang at the bottom, and the first stop of "the sovereign emerges in Zhen" ↗

Trigram imagery: why a round clay bowl has two possible routes ↗

Recording six coin throws: keep states and moving lines ↗