Knowledge library
BZ-NY-23 / BaZi

Great Post Road Earth: Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster

Content version · · Sources & references

Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster: Post Road Earth
Save share card ↓

Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster share the twenty-third Na Yin name. The Sanming Tonghui reads Monkey as Kun and Rooster as Dui, then calls Yang Earth Monkey “earth at Growth”; two stage tables, pairings, years.

The short version10 min read

There is no metal in the name, yet each pillar is earth sitting on metal. Earth of the Great Post Road, the Na Yin of Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster, takes the Monkey as Kun, the ground, and the Rooster as Dui, the marsh, with the two Earth stems laid on top: a level highway to all nine provinces.

  • Both stems are Earth and both branches are Metal, so Earth sits above Metal; the “road” is not any one character in the pillar but the picture the name borrows.
  • The entry calls Yang Earth Monkey “earth at Growth” and Yin Earth Rooster “self-defeated”, on juan 1’s water-and-earth count for Na Yin earth; this site’s stem table follows juan 2, with Growth at the Tiger for Yang Earth and at the Rooster for Yin Earth.
  • Four of the six pairings picked here carry a Punishment, Harm or Clash in the branch table, yet the book still rates them “also good”, “favorable in reverse”, “noble” or “fine alone”; it seems to rate Na Yin pairings.
Earth over Metal in both pillars; the Monkey is Kun, the ground, the Rooster Dui, the marsh, with the Earth stems laid on top. The last scene asks what “earth at Growth” means: which stage table, whose entry, and when 1969’s Start of Spring fell.

Read first

What is Na Yin in BaZi? Why Yang Wood Rat Gold in the Sea does not replace Yang Wood ↗

Monkey and Rooster: the crossroads where things settle

The twenty-third Na Yin name, Earth of the Great Post Road (大驿土), is shared by Yang Earth Monkey (戊申) and Yin Earth Rooster (己酉). The stems, Yang Earth and Yin Earth, are both Earth, the branches Monkey and Rooster are Metal, so Earth sits above Metal. Yet the name has no metal in it; it describes a road.

Table comparing Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster: both stems are Earth, both branches are Metal, both carry the Na Yin Earth of the Great Post Road; in the calendar specialists’ saying the Monkey belongs to Kun, the earth, and the Rooster to Dui, the marsh.Open the full-size diagram

Comparison sketch: stem and branch attributes use the usual entry-level assignments, the Na Yin name follows the Sanming Tonghui, and the last column gives the trigrams used in the calendar specialists’ saying.

The last column of the picture holds the trigrams the calendar specialists (日家) used for the name. They pair the Monkey with Kun (坤), the ground, and the Rooster with Dui (兑), the marsh. Inside the Monkey sit Yang Metal, Yang Water and Yang Earth, inside the Rooster only Yin Metal, and that is where the branches take their Metal; Earth produces Metal, so the stem Earth feeds the branch Metal below it.

The first volume of the Sanming Tonghui (三命通会) sorts the twelve branches in pairs. Of the Monkey and the Rooster it says that yin and yang are in their withering phase, things are already harvested, and people have drawn in, each settled in stillness. For this pair of pillars it then writes:

Yang Earth Monkey and Yin Earth Rooster: the qi has gone home to rest, things are gathered in, drawn back and retired, beautiful and with nothing to do. So it is called Earth of the Great Post Road.

Sanming Tonghui, vol. 1, On the Images of Na Yin, which groups branches in pairs; our rendering

“Rest” and “gathered in” are the quiet after a harvest, and “nothing to do” means this earth has nothing left to hurry for. Yet the name is a post station, a big stop on a road, and the next passage puts that quiet onto the road.

Kun and Dui: setting earth on the ground and a marsh

A post station was a relay stop on an imperial road. The entry opens with a picture, then says where this earth lies and what it is like:

The great post road: a broad highway and a level road, with no province of the nine unreached and no state of the ten thousand not arrived at. Its place is on the side of Kun, and its virtue is to bear.

Sanming Tonghui, vol. 1, opening of the entry for this earth; our rendering

Kun is the earth among the trigrams: “on the side of Kun” puts it in that direction, and “its virtue is to bear” gives its character as carrying.

The second reason comes from the calendar specialists and switches to trigrams. The Monkey is Kun’s, and Kun is the ground; the Rooster is Dui’s, and Dui is the marsh. Yang Earth and Yin Earth are set on top of the two, so the book says it is “not comparable to any other thin, floating soil”. The Xieji Bianfang Shu (协纪辨方书), juan 1, carries the same saying.

Both accounts end on sturdy earth carried by ground and marsh. Later in the same section, appraising six kinds of earth, the book adds that the post road’s earth reaches every direction and that the Monkey and Rooster fit “finding friends, to profit and flourish”, a line to read beside the Kun hexagram’s “in the southwest, gain friends”.

The picture in the entryBroad highwayall nine provincesSide of Kunvirtue of bearingPost RoadEarthsea and mountainThe calendar specialists’ reasonMonkey:Kunthe earthRooster:Duithe marshThe twoEarth stemslaid on topPost RoadEarthnot thin soilBoth paths end on sturdy earth; one speaks of a road, the other of trigram positions
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
The picture in the entryBroad highwayall nine provincesSide of Kunvirtue of bearingPost RoadEarthsea and mountainThe calendar specialists’ reasonMonkey:Kunthe earthRooster:Duithe marshThe twoEarth stemslaid on topPost RoadEarthnot thin soilBoth paths end on sturdy earth; one speaks of a road, the other of trigram positions
Two paths to the name: the entry pictures a highway on the side of Kun with a bearing virtue; the calendar specialists say the Monkey is Kun, the earth, the Rooster is Dui, the marsh, and the two Earth stems are laid over them.

“Earth at Growth”: a phrase in the book and a position in the table

After the name, the entry turns to what this earth should be paired with, and its first sentence already uses words from the twelve-stage table:

It brings forth the ten thousand things, with wood as its base. Yang Earth Monkey is earth at Growth, its virtue thick and without limit, and it is nourished by three or four woods; Yin Earth Rooster is self-defeated earth, and too much wood draws off its qi.

Sanming Tonghui, vol. 1, the entry’s first line on wood; our rendering

In older books Bath is also called “defeat”, so this sentence starts Earth’s Growth at the Monkey, with Bath on the Rooster. That is the water-and-earth count juan 1 uses for Na Yin earth; its pillar-by-pillar commentary likewise says Yang Earth Monkey “grows by itself”. This site’s table answers another question: it looks up a Day Master by stem and follows juan 2, where fire and earth go together, so Yang Earth begins Growth at the Tiger and Yin Earth at the Rooster. There Yang Earth on the Monkey is Weakening, while Yin Earth on the Rooster is Growth. Below, “Growth” and “self-defeated” in the entry and the commentary are read on the water-and-earth count.

The entry’s countWater and earth share a palace: Growth at the MonkeyMonkey: Growth → Yang Earth MonkeyRooster: Bath, once called defeat → Yin Earth RoosterDog: Coming of AgePig: EstablishmentThis site’s table, by stemJuan 2, fire and earth share a palaceYang Earth: Growth at the TigerYang Earth on the Monkey: WeakeningYin Earth: Growth at the RoosterYin Earth on the Monkey: BathThe left column is juan 1’s count for Na Yin earth; the right column is the count for a Day Master looked up by stem. They answer different questions
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
The entry’s countWater and earth share a palace: Growth at the MonkeyMonkey: Growth → Yang Earth MonkeyRooster: Bath, once called defeat → Yin Earth RoosterDog: Coming of AgePig: EstablishmentThis site’s table, by stemJuan 2, fire and earth share a palaceYang Earth: Growth at the TigerYang Earth on the Monkey: WeakeningYin Earth: Growth at the RoosterYin Earth on the Monkey: BathThe left column is juan 1’s count for Na Yin earth; the right column is the count for a Day Master looked up by stem. They answer different questions
The entry counts water and earth together, placing Earth’s Growth at the Monkey, so Yang Earth Monkey is earth at Growth and Yin Earth Rooster self-defeated earth; this site’s stem table follows juan 2, with Yang Earth at Growth on the Tiger and Weakening on the Monkey, and Yin Earth at Growth on the Rooster.

Juan 2 takes up the difference in its section on the birth and death of the stems. It holds that Yang Earth is born at the Tiger and Yin Earth at the Rooster and calls the Monkey count “badly mistaken”; then it records the yin-yang school’s view that water and earth are born together at the Monkey, grants that this “also has its reason”, and calls earth “one thing with two births”. When a passage says “earth at Growth”, first ask which table it counts on. The full ring of twelve stages is drawn in the stage table and void branches.

Water and metal: six pairings against the table

After the stage words, the entry goes through wood, water, fire, earth and metal, naming what is welcome and what is not. Water and metal are named down to the pillar, so six of those pairings are picked out below and checked against the engine’s tables:

PairingNa YinWhat the book saysWhat the table findsYin Earth Rooster + Yang Wood MonkeyWater in the SpringOfficial and noble; auspiciousYin Earth–Yang Wood combine; no branch relationYang Earth Monkey + Yin Water SnakeLong Flowing WaterAlso good; restless if met oftenYang Earth–Yin Water combine; Snake–Monkey combine and punishYin Earth Rooster + Yang Water DragonLong Flowing WaterAlso goodDragon–Rooster Six HarmonyYang Earth Monkey + Yin Water PigWater of the Great SeaYang Earth–Yin Water combine; “earth and heaven in accord”Yang Earth–Yin Water combine; Monkey–Pig HarmYang Earth Monkey + Yin Metal Pig or Yang Water TigerHairpin and Bracelet Metal, Gold Foil MetalWith water to help, “earth and heaven in accord”, a great noble patternMonkey–Pig Harm; Tiger–Monkey Clash and PunishmentYin Wood RabbitWater of the Great StreamEast, thunder, birth; fine aloneClashes with Yin Earth Rooster; none with Yang Earth MonkeyThe right column comes from the engine’s stem and branch relation tables; the entry names many more pairings, and one or two of each kind are picked here; the book does not say which pillar the Yin Wood Rabbit line goes with
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
PairingNa YinWhat the book saysWhat the table findsYin Earth Rooster + Yang Wood MonkeyWater in the SpringOfficial and noble; auspiciousYin Earth–Yang Wood combine; no branch relationYang Earth Monkey + Yin Water SnakeLong Flowing WaterAlso good; restless if met oftenYang Earth–Yin Water combine; Snake–Monkey combine and punishYin Earth Rooster + Yang Water DragonLong Flowing WaterAlso goodDragon–Rooster Six HarmonyYang Earth Monkey + Yin Water PigWater of the Great SeaYang Earth–Yin Water combine; “earth and heaven in accord”Yang Earth–Yin Water combine; Monkey–Pig HarmYang Earth Monkey + Yin Metal Pig or Yang Water TigerHairpin and Bracelet Metal, Gold Foil MetalWith water to help, “earth and heaven in accord”, a great noble patternMonkey–Pig Harm; Tiger–Monkey Clash and PunishmentYin Wood RabbitWater of the Great StreamEast, thunder, birth; fine aloneClashes with Yin Earth Rooster; none with Yang Earth MonkeyThe right column comes from the engine’s stem and branch relation tables; the entry names many more pairings, and one or two of each kind are picked here; the book does not say which pillar the Yin Wood Rabbit line goes with
Six pairings picked from the entry for the post road earth, with their table counterparts: Yin Earth Rooster with Yang Wood Monkey, Yang Earth Monkey with Yin Water Snake, Yin Earth Rooster with Yang Water Dragon, Yang Earth Monkey with Yin Water Pig, Yang Earth Monkey with Yin Metal Pig or Yang Water Tiger, and Yin Wood Rabbit.

Row by row: Yang Earth and Yin Water combine as stems, so both Yin Water Snake and Yin Water Pig have that tie with Yang Earth Monkey. The Pig against the Monkey, in Yin Water Pig and Yin Metal Pig alike, is a Harm and the Tiger against the Monkey a Clash, yet the book downgrades neither and even writes the Yin Water Pig line as “favorable in reverse”. The entry seems to rate the pattern of the Na Yin pairing, not branch relations pillar by pillar.

4 February 1969: two year pillars either side of spring

1968 is a Yang Earth Monkey year and 1969 a Yin Earth Rooster year, as are 2028–2029 and 1908–1909. The pillar turns at the Start of Spring (立春), not on 1 January: 02:07 on 5 February 1968, 07:58 on 4 February 1969 and 13:45 on 4 February 1970 (Beijing time). On 4 February 1969, people born before and after 07:58 carry different year pillars.

Year pillar Yang Earth MonkeyYear pillar Yin Earth RoosterSpring 07:5806:00 · Yang Earth Monkey year10:00 · Yin Earth Rooster yearThe axis shows clock hours on 4 February 1969; before the Start of Spring the year pillar is still Yang Earth Monkey
Enlarge diagram · scroll sideways to read
Year pillar Yang Earth MonkeyYear pillar Yin Earth RoosterSpring 07:5806:00 · Yang Earth Monkey year10:00 · Yin Earth Rooster yearThe axis shows clock hours on 4 February 1969; before the Start of Spring the year pillar is still Yang Earth Monkey
Born before 07:58 on 4 February 1969 the year pillar is Yang Earth Monkey, and after it Yin Earth Rooster; both pillars carry the Na Yin Earth of the Great Post Road.

Two exercises

Exercise one

Born at 6 a.m. on 4 February 1969: what is the year pillar?

6 a.m. comes ahead of the 07:58 Start of Spring, which leaves the year at Yang Earth Monkey; at 10 a.m. it is Yin Earth Rooster. Both carry Earth of the Great Post Road.

Exercise two

The day pillar is Yin Earth Rooster and the month pillar is Yin Wood Rabbit: what does the entry say of that pairing?

The entry only says that Yin Wood Rabbit of the great stream, “east, thunder, birth”, is fine alone; it does not mention Yin Earth Rooster. In the table the Rabbit and the Rooster clash, a layer that needs its own source and cannot be settled by “fine alone”.

Just before it in the sixty-cycle comes Water of the Heavenly River, just after it Hairpin and Bracelet Metal, and the book sets it against Earth on the City Wall half a circle away. How Na Yin divides the work with the plain elements is laid out in Na Yin versus the regular five elements.

Questions readers ask next

The book calls Yang Earth Monkey “earth at Growth”, but this site’s table puts Yang Earth on the Monkey at Weakening. Why?

The two tables answer different questions. The entry’s “earth at Growth” uses juan 1’s count for Na Yin earth, with water and earth together and Growth at the Monkey. This site’s table looks up a Day Master by stem and follows juan 2, where fire and earth go together: Yang Earth begins at the Tiger and Yin Earth at the Rooster, so Yang Earth on the Monkey is Weakening. Juan 2 discusses both, prefers fire with earth, and grants that earth with water “also has its reason”. Both are shown side by side and neither is rewritten into the other.

Someone born at 6 a.m. on 4 February 1969: is the year pillar Yang Earth Monkey or Yin Earth Rooster?

Yang Earth Monkey. The Start of Spring in 1969 fell at 07:58 Beijing time on 4 February, and 6 a.m. is before it, so the year pillar still belongs to the previous year. Someone born at 10 a.m. has Yin Earth Rooster. Both pillars carry the same Na Yin.

Why are the City Wall and the Great Post Road so often read as a pair?

Both have Earth stems, Yang Earth and Yin Earth, but their branches sit half a circle apart: the Tiger and Rabbit for the wall, which takes the image of Gen, a mountain, and the Monkey and Rooster for the road, which takes Kun and Dui. On the Images of Na Yin sets the two side by side with the words “east, south, west, north: the proper places of Kun and Gen”; Gen lies northeast and Kun southwest.

Was this article helpful?

Sources & references

  1. 維基文庫・三命通會(四庫全書本)・卷一 ↗
  2. 維基文庫・欽定協紀辨方書(四庫全書本)・卷一 ↗
  3. 香港天文台:天干和地支,六十干支表 ↗

Continue reading

Water of the Heavenly River (天河水): Why Yang Fire Horse and Yin Fire Goat Carry This Name ↗

Hairpin and Bracelet Metal (钗钏金): Yang Metal Dog, Yin Metal Pig, Last of Six Metals ↗

Five Elements cycles: learn the relationships, not just the order ↗